Dialogue Grading Grid

Grading Grid: Dialogue of Ideas

Name:

1. Multiple Perspectives: Dialogue makes major arguments from multiple perspectives; goes beyond right/wrong moral dialectic; major arguments have evidence and secondary claims supporting them; arguments are original in character: they don't resemble cliched points of view; (30%)

1              5              6              7              8              9              10

2. Evidence: Dialogue contains research incorporated as supporting claims for all sides of major arguments; evidence is coherent with arguments; at least 25-33% of sources are academic, peer-reviewed sources; footnotes contain basic citation information (MLA data, if not in MLA order); (30%)

1              5              6              7              8              9              10

3. Performance/Length: Dialogue (as) performed is 5-7 minutes in length (approximately 3-5 pages) unless otherwise permitted; (20%)

1              5              6              7              8              9              10

4. Style/Revision: Dialogue went through peer review drafting process; displays toward authentic voices, positions, and characterization; is free of casual errors; (20%)

1              5              6              7              8              9              10

Grade:

Comments: